# Étoile d'une Nuit vs For Her Musc Noir Rose

Étoile d'une Nuit and For Her Musc Noir Rose overlap 46% in notes and accords; 3 notes appear in both. For Her Musc Noir Rose projects more: sillage 7.2/10 against 6.6/10 for Étoile d'une Nuit. For Her Musc Noir Rose rates higher with the community: 8.2/10 against 7.9/10 for Étoile d'une Nuit.

## At a glance

|  | Étoile d'une Nuit | For Her Musc Noir Rose |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Brand | Goutal | Narciso Rodriguez |
| Release year | 2019 | 2022 |
| Rating | 7.9/10 | 8.2/10 |
| Longevity | 7.2/10 | 7.4/10 |
| Sillage | 6.6/10 | 7.2/10 |

## Seasons

|  | Étoile d'une Nuit | For Her Musc Noir Rose |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Autumn | 31% | 34% |
| Spring | 31% | 26% |
| Winter | 24% | 28% |
| Summer | 15% | 12% |

## Occasions

|  | Étoile d'une Nuit | For Her Musc Noir Rose |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Evening | 20% | 22% |
| Casual | 21% | 20% |
| Daytime | 21% | 20% |
| Nighttime | 18% | 21% |
| Office | 19% | 15% |

## Notes

In both: Italian bergamot, Musk, Vanilla

Only in this one:

- Étoile d'une Nuit: Blackberry, Italian mandarin orange, Egyptian jasmine, Iris, Rose, Cashmere wood
- For Her Musc Noir Rose: Pink pepper, Tuberose, Plum, Suede, Indonesian patchouli

## Accords

- Étoile d'une Nuit: Floral, Fruity, Sweet, Powdery, Creamy
- For Her Musc Noir Rose: Floral, Fruity, Sweet, Spicy, Powdery, Creamy

## Frequently asked questions

### Which one lasts longer?

Their longevity is about the same: 7.2/10 for Étoile d'une Nuit, 7.4/10 for For Her Musc Noir Rose.

### Which one projects more?

For Her Musc Noir Rose projects more: sillage 7.2/10 against 6.6/10 for Étoile d'une Nuit.

### Which one suits winter better?

Both suit winter about equally: winter gets 24% of the season votes for Étoile d'une Nuit and 28% for For Her Musc Noir Rose.

### Which one suits summer better?

Both suit summer about equally: summer gets 15% of the season votes for Étoile d'une Nuit and 12% for For Her Musc Noir Rose.

### Which one is rated higher?

For Her Musc Noir Rose is rated higher: 8.2/10 against 7.9/10 for Étoile d'une Nuit.

### Which notes do they share?

Notes found in both: Italian bergamot, Musk, Vanilla.

## More

- [Étoile d'une Nuit details](https://parfumedia.net/en/perfumes/goutal-etoile-d-une-nuit)
- [Étoile d'une Nuit dupes and similar perfumes](https://parfumedia.net/en/dupes/goutal-etoile-d-une-nuit)
- [For Her Musc Noir Rose details](https://parfumedia.net/en/perfumes/narciso-rodriguez-for-her-musc-noir-rose)
- [For Her Musc Noir Rose dupes and similar perfumes](https://parfumedia.net/en/dupes/narciso-rodriguez-for-her-musc-noir-rose)

https://parfumedia.net/en/compare/goutal-etoile-d-une-nuit-vs-narciso-rodriguez-for-her-musc-noir-rose