Skip to content
Parfumedia

For Her Musc Noir Rose vs Valentino Donna (2015)

Narciso Rodriguez For Her Musc Noir Rose perfume bottle

Narciso Rodriguez

For Her Musc Noir Rose

Valentino Donna (2015) (Eau de Parfum) perfume bottle

Valentino

Valentino Donna (2015)

For Her Musc Noir Rose and Valentino Donna (2015) share 3 of their 11 notes (27%). For Her Musc Noir Rose is rated higher: 8.0/10 against 7.5/10 for Valentino Donna (2015).

Download image

Square 1080 × 1080Story 1080 × 1920

At a glance

For Her Musc Noir RoseValentino Donna (2015)
BrandNarciso RodriguezValentino
Release year20222015
ConcentrationNo dataEau de Parfum
Rating
8.0/101,000+ votes
7.5/10100+ votes
Longevity
7.5/10
7.5/10
Sillage
7.0/10
7.0/10

When to wear

Seasons
For Her Musc Noir RoseValentino Donna (2015)
Autumn34%31%
Spring26%29%
Winter28%24%
Summer12%16%
Occasions
For Her Musc Noir RoseValentino Donna (2015)
Evening22%20%
Nighttime21%21%
Casual20%21%
Daytime20%20%
Office15%17%

Notes

3 of 11 notes in both (27%)

Only in For Her Musc Noir Rose

  • Pink pepper
  • Musk
  • Tuberose
  • Plum
  • Suede

In both

  • Bergamot(Italian bergamot / Calabrian bergamot)
  • Vanilla
  • Patchouli(Indonesian patchouli)

Only in Valentino Donna (2015)

  • Iris pallida(Italian iris pallida)
  • Rose(Bulgarian damask rose)
  • Leather(Italian leather)

Accords

  1. Floral: For Her Musc Noir Rose, Valentino Donna (2015)
  2. Fruity: For Her Musc Noir Rose, Valentino Donna (2015)
  3. Sweet: For Her Musc Noir Rose, Valentino Donna (2015)
  4. Spicy: For Her Musc Noir Rose, Valentino Donna (2015)
  5. Powdery: For Her Musc Noir Rose, Valentino Donna (2015)
  6. Creamy: For Her Musc Noir Rose
  7. Leathery: Valentino Donna (2015)

Frequently asked questions

Which one lasts longer?

Their longevity is about the same: 7.5/10 for For Her Musc Noir Rose, 7.5/10 for Valentino Donna (2015).

Which one projects more?

Their sillage is about the same: 7.0/10 for For Her Musc Noir Rose, 7.0/10 for Valentino Donna (2015).

Which one suits winter better?

Both suit winter about equally: winter gets 28% of the season votes for For Her Musc Noir Rose and 24% for Valentino Donna (2015).

Which one suits summer better?

Both suit summer about equally: summer gets 12% of the season votes for For Her Musc Noir Rose and 16% for Valentino Donna (2015).

Which one is rated higher?

For Her Musc Noir Rose is rated higher: 8.0/10 against 7.5/10 for Valentino Donna (2015).

Which notes do they share?

Notes found in both: Bergamot (Italian bergamot / Calabrian bergamot), Vanilla, Patchouli (Indonesian patchouli).

Compare For Her Musc Noir Rose with another perfume

People also compared

More