Based on brands' own pages. Last checked November 2, 2026.
Dupes whose brands say they are inspired by Bath & Body Works Milk Bar Birthday Cake: The Dua Brand Frosted With Sprinkles - Milk Bar Birthday Cake Bath And Body Works. These matches rest on the maker’s own statement or on several independent sources. Original alternatives with the closest notes and accords: Sugar Milk! Birthday Cake! (87% note/accord overlap), Demeter Fragrance Library Vanilla Cake Batter (Cologne) (83%), The Dua Brand Whipped French Vanilla (80%).
Finished perfume · Eau de Parfum
The brand says this is inspired by Bath & Body Works Milk Bar Birthday Cake.
“Frosted With Sprinkles - Milk Bar Birthday Cake Bath And Body Works”
Source: theduabrand.com
Last seen November 2, 2026
Does it smell alike?
Similarity is the share of common notes (60%) and common accords (40%).
83% similarDemeter Fragrance Library
83% overlap
Shared notes: Vanilla cake
80% similarThe Dua Brand · 2022
80% overlap
Shared notes: Sugar icing
79% similarDemeter Fragrance Library
79% overlap
75% similarChabaud
75% overlap
| Perfume | Type | Note/accord overlap | Shared notes | Longevity | Sillage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bath & Body Works Milk Bar Birthday Cake | Original | No data | No data | 5.5/10 (10+ votes) | No data |
| Sugar Milk! Birthday Cake! | Similar original | 87% | Sprinkles, Sugar icing | No data | No data |
| Demeter Fragrance Library Vanilla Cake Batter (Cologne) | Similar original | 83% | Vanilla cake | 5.0/10 (10+ votes) | 5.0/10 (10+ votes) |
| The Dua Brand Whipped French Vanilla | Similar original | 80% | Sugar icing | No data | No data |
Dupes said by sources to be inspired by Bath & Body Works Milk Bar Birthday Cake: The Dua Brand Frosted With Sprinkles - Milk Bar Birthday Cake Bath And Body Works: several independent sources.
By note and accord overlap the closest original is Sugar Milk! Birthday Cake! (87%). Shared notes: Sprinkles, Sugar icing. Other close alternatives: Demeter Fragrance Library Vanilla Cake Batter (Cologne) (83%), The Dua Brand Whipped French Vanilla (80%).
Coded dupes are compiled from maker pages and independent sources. "Stated by the maker": the dupe maker’s own statement. "Several independent sources": at least two sources that do not copy each other give the same match. "Single source family (community)": only one community source family, counting sites that copy each other as one. "Parfumedia compilation": a match compiled by Parfumedia from brand materials and independent sources.
The percentage for similar originals is the share of common notes (60% weight) and common accords (40% weight).
Dupe matches were last checked on November 3, 2026.
