Skip to content
Parfumedia

Perfumes similar to Peanut Butter Pony

The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Astrid Perfume Peanut Butter Pony. The closest match is Poesie Perfume Frosted. The notes shared most often on this list: Marshmallow, Buttercream, and Biscuit.

Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Back to Peanut Butter Pony
  1. Poesie Perfume Frosted perfume bottle

    Frosted

    Poesie Perfume · 2017

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  2. Cocoa Pink Frosted Eyelet perfume bottle

    Frosted Eyelet

    7.2

    Cocoa Pink · 2013

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  3. Possets Maggie perfume bottle

    Maggie

    Possets · 2007

    Shared notes
    Biscuit, Marshmallow
  4. Cocoa Pink Apricot Eyelet perfume bottle

    Apricot Eyelet

    Cocoa Pink · 2013

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  5. Hexennacht Raspberry Rosemallow perfume bottle

    Raspberry Rosemallow

    Hexennacht · 2018

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  6. Hexennacht Chai-mallow perfume bottle

    Chai-mallow

    Hexennacht

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  7. Cocoa Pink Ivory Eyelet perfume bottle

    Ivory Eyelet

    Cocoa Pink

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  8. Happy Place Cosmetics Buffday Kake perfume bottle

    Buffday Kake

    Happy Place Cosmetics

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  9. Hexennacht Fluffernutter perfume bottle

    Fluffernutter

    Hexennacht · 2021

    Shared notes
    Marshmallow, Peanut butter
  10. Astrid Perfume Deliciously Chilling perfume bottle

    Deliciously Chilling

    Astrid Perfume · 2017

    Shared notes
    Biscuit, Marshmallow
  11. Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab Cerberus'ish perfume bottle

    Cerberus'ish

    Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab · 2021

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  12. Cocoa Pink Cranberry Eyelet perfume bottle

    Cranberry Eyelet

    Cocoa Pink

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  13. Hexennacht Mochamallow perfume bottle

    Mochamallow

    Hexennacht

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  14. Cocoa Pink Kiwi Eyelet perfume bottle

    Kiwi Eyelet

    Cocoa Pink · 2013

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  15. Solstice Scents Snowmint Mallow (Perfume) perfume bottle

    Snowmint Mallow (Perfume)

    Solstice Scents · 2013

    Shared notes
    Biscuit, Marshmallow
  16. Cocoa Pink Cauldron Bubbles perfume bottle

    Cauldron Bubbles

    Cocoa Pink

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  17. Poesie Perfume Tiny Phantom perfume bottle

    Tiny Phantom

    Poesie Perfume · 2017

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  18. Kheimistrii Strawberry Sugar Cookie perfume bottle

    Strawberry Sugar Cookie

    Kheimistrii

    Shared notes
    Biscuit, Buttercream
  19. Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab Indigestion perfume bottle

    Indigestion

    Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab · 2025

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow
  20. Hexennacht Arsenic perfume bottle

    Arsenic

    7.8

    Hexennacht

    Shared notes
    Biscuit, Buttercream
  21. Cocoa Pink Marshmallow Sunrise perfume bottle

    Marshmallow Sunrise

    Cocoa Pink · 2014

    Shared notes
    Biscuit, Marshmallow
  22. Sixteen92 Such a Misfit perfume bottle

    Such a Misfit

    Sixteen92 · 2018

    Shared notes
    Biscuit, Marshmallow
  23. Astrid Perfume Whinnies No. 6 (2021) perfume bottle

    Whinnies No. 6 (2021)

    Astrid Perfume · 2021

    Shared notes
    Marshmallow, Peanut butter
  24. Hexennacht Pastel Goth perfume bottle

    Pastel Goth

    Hexennacht

    Shared notes
    Buttercream, Marshmallow