Perfumes similar to Whinnies No. 12 (2016)
The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Astrid Perfume Whinnies No. 12 (2016). The closest match is Ghalati Etoile. The notes shared most often on this list: Vanilla, Frankincense, and Marshmallow.
Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Etoile
Ghalati
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Marshmallow, Vanilla

Aisha Kandisha
Common Brimstone · 2016
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Pomegranate, Vanilla

Nafhat Al-Bukhor
Mishal Muzaffar Atarji
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Juzoor Al Oud
Mishal Muzaffar Atarji
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Albulaan
Hekate · 2021
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Marshmallow Cake Batter
Ten Digit Creations
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow, Vanilla

Velvet Vanilla
Tanya Burr Cosmetics · 2017
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Creepy & Crawly
Astrid Perfume · 2014
- Shared notes
- Black liquorice, Marshmallow

Jazz
yogesh
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Santal Cacao
Hexennacht · 2025
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Marshmallow, Vanilla

Marshmallow
Arcana Wildcraft
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow, Vanilla

Vanilla Vibes
scentXscent · 2025
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow, Vanilla

Vanilla Silk
Ten Digit Creations
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow, Vanilla

Nuit D'Ylang
Darkbeat · 2021
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Pomegranate, Vanilla

Pas de Velours
8.1Les Néréides · 2020
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Delizia di Marshmallow
8.1Kyse Perfumes · 2019
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow, Vanilla

Encens et lavande
7.5Serge Lutens · 1996
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Rose Marshmallow Candy
6.3Zara · 2020
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow, Vanilla

What the Fluff
9.1Aspiring Aromas · 2024
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow, Vanilla

Fame The Couture Edition
7.3Rabanne · 2025
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Marshmallow Crush
8.1Parfums by Chérie · 2025
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow, Vanilla

La Nuit des Temps
7.5Camille Leguay · 2023
- Shared notes
- Frankincense, Vanilla

Amyaz Shay
Anfasic Dokhoon
- Shared notes
- Pomegranate, Vanilla

Fleur d'Hibiscus
Adopt'
- Shared notes
- Pomegranate, Vanilla