Perfumes similar to Whinnies No. 9 (2017)
The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Astrid Perfume Whinnies No. 9 (2017). The closest match is Clubman Brandy Spice. The notes shared most often on this list: Carnation, Apple, and Marshmallow.
Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Brandy Spice
Clubman · 2017
- Shared notes
- Apple, Citrus zest

Linger
Scentsy
- Shared notes
- Apple, Marshmallow

Peony & Rose
Whiff (PHL)
- Shared notes
- Apple, Carnation

Apple Kiss Kiss
Wylde Ivy · 2013
- Shared notes
- Apple, Marshmallow

Karafiát Klinec
5.6Alpa
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Green Surprise
5.2Mel Merio
- Shared notes
- Apple

Pomme de Reinette
Yves Rocher · 1999
- Shared notes
- Apple

Garofano
Santa Maria Novella
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Golconda
JAR Parfums
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Zozimus
Hexennacht
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow

Sublimate
Amphora Parfum · 2024
- Shared notes
- Apple, Marshmallow

Christmas Bouquet (Cologne)
Demeter Fragrance Library · 2011
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Bachagaloop
Heist Fragrances
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow

Carnation (Perfume)
Hové
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Marshmallow
Haus of Gloi · 2020
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow

Red Carnation
Henri Rénaud
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Œillet
Mury
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Dianthus (Solid Perfume)
For Strange Women · 2021
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Silver Carnations
Possets · 2007
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Marshmallow
Cocoa Pink
- Shared notes
- Marshmallow

Marshmallow
Tutti Délices · 2026
- Shared notes
- Apple, Marshmallow

Pomme
Outremer
- Shared notes
- Apple

Dianthus Enfleurage
Wild Veil Perfume
- Shared notes
- Carnation

Insolence Eau Glacée
7.3Guerlain · 2009
- Shared notes
- Apple, Citrus zest