Skip to content
Parfumedia

Perfumes similar to Calico Jack's Original Bay Rum

The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Cherry City Shave Products Calico Jack's Original Bay Rum. The closest match is Primitive Outpost Spiced Bay Rum (After Shave). The notes shared most often on this list: Lime, Vanilla, and Black pepper.

Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Back to Calico Jack's Original Bay Rum
  1. Primitive Outpost Spiced Bay Rum (After Shave) perfume bottle

    Spiced Bay Rum (After Shave)

    Primitive Outpost

    Shared notes
    Bay rum, Lime, Pimento, Vanilla
  2. M. Asam Limette Vanille perfume bottle

    Limette Vanille

    7.6

    M. Asam

    Shared notes
    Lime, Vanilla
  3. Perlier Caribbean Vanilla - Vanilla Lime perfume bottle

    Caribbean Vanilla - Vanilla Lime

    Perlier

    Shared notes
    Lime, Vanilla
  4. St James of London Black Pepper & Lime perfume bottle

    Black Pepper & Lime

    St James of London

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Lime
  5. Black Ship Grooming Co. Black Beard perfume bottle

    Black Beard

    Black Ship Grooming Co.

    Shared notes
    Bay rum, Lime
  6. Ten Digit Creations Vanilla Lime perfume bottle

    Vanilla Lime

    Ten Digit Creations

    Shared notes
    Lime, Vanilla
  7. Long Rifle Bay Rhum perfume bottle

    Bay Rhum

    Long Rifle

    Shared notes
    Bay rum, Lime
  8. Greenland Fruit Emotions - Lime-Vanilla perfume bottle

    Fruit Emotions - Lime-Vanilla

    Greenland

    Shared notes
    Lime, Vanilla
  9. Saint Charles Shave Bay Rum With a Twist perfume bottle

    Bay Rum With a Twist

    Saint Charles Shave

    Shared notes
    Bay rum, Lime
  10. Ogallala Bay Rum Bay Rum & Vanilla perfume bottle

    Bay Rum & Vanilla

    Ogallala Bay Rum

    Shared notes
    Bay rum, Vanilla
  11. Sucreabeille Gryla (Perfume Oil) perfume bottle

    Gryla (Perfume Oil)

    Sucreabeille

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Vanilla
  12. Avery Perfume Gallery A (Perfume) perfume bottle

    A (Perfume)

    Avery Perfume Gallery · 2014

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Lime, Vanilla
  13. Avery Perfume Gallery Ambre Amant (Hair Perfume) perfume bottle

    Ambre Amant (Hair Perfume)

    Avery Perfume Gallery · 2018

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Lime, Vanilla
  14. Rouge & Rye Lillian perfume bottle

    Lillian

    Rouge & Rye · 2015

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Pimento, Vanilla
  15. Phoenix and Beau Imperial Rum (Aftershave) perfume bottle

    Imperial Rum (Aftershave)

    Phoenix and Beau · 2019

    Shared notes
    Bay rum, Lime, Pimento
  16. Providence Perfume Bay Rum perfume bottle

    Bay Rum

    7.3

    Providence Perfume · 2014

    Shared notes
    Bay rum, Lime, Pimento
  17. The Body Shop Full Ylang Ylang perfume bottle

    Full Ylang Ylang

    6.0

    The Body Shop · 2023

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Vanilla
  18. Pacific Perfumes Love The Mango (Solid Perfume) perfume bottle

    Love The Mango (Solid Perfume)

    Pacific Perfumes

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Lime
  19. Element Botanicals Black Moon perfume bottle

    Black Moon

    Element Botanicals

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Vanilla
  20. Abelha Rainha Narcizo perfume bottle

    Narcizo

    Abelha Rainha

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Lime
  21. Deep Midnight Perfumes Bourbon Street perfume bottle

    Bourbon Street

    Deep Midnight Perfumes · 2010

    Shared notes
    Bay rum, Vanilla
  22. Aquaflor A La Russe - Rouge perfume bottle

    A La Russe - Rouge

    Aquaflor · 2014

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Vanilla
  23. Badass Beard Care The Outlaw perfume bottle

    The Outlaw

    Badass Beard Care

    Shared notes
    Black pepper, Vanilla
  24. Josie Maran Passion - Vanilla Fig perfume bottle

    Passion - Vanilla Fig

    Josie Maran

    Shared notes
    Lime, Vanilla