Perfumes similar to Anne Bonny (Aftershave)
The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Dr. Jon's Anne Bonny (Aftershave). The closest match is Col. Ichabod Conk Bay Rum - After Shave - Cologne. The notes shared most often on this list: Rum, Lime, and Laurel.
Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Bay Rum - After Shave - Cologne
Col. Ichabod Conk
- Shared notes
- Laurel, Rum

Barbados
D.S. & Durga · 2008
- Shared notes
- Laurel, Lime, Rum

Divine Essence 2 / Warm Herbal Citrus
JoAnne Bassett · 2005
- Shared notes
- Laurel, Lime

Bay Rum
Excelsis
- Shared notes
- Laurel, Rum

Spiced Lime
St. Kitts Herbery
- Shared notes
- Laurel, Lime

Guerlain Homme L'Eau Boisée
7.7Guerlain · 2012
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Mojito (Cologne)
5.0Demeter Fragrance Library
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Coconut Mojito (Parfum Mist)
Dirty Soul Soap Co.
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Cuban Highball
A & E - Ariana & Evans
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Lavender Mojito
Haus of Gloi · 2017
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Strawberry Daiquiri
Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab · 2025
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Daydream
ERIIY
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Business as Usual
The Man Brand
- Shared notes
- Laurel, Rum

Chats with Grandpa
Hub City Soap Company
- Shared notes
- Laurel, Rum

Mal.
brudi
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Malibù - Party in the Bay
8.3Simone Andreoli · 2018
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Cubalibre
6.7Mallo · 2022
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

L'Eau à la Bouche / FR! 01 | N° 03
6.3Le Cercle des Parfumeurs Createurs · 2013
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Strawberry Panna Cotta
6.9Ganache Parfums · 2017
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Lemon Ice Tea
Mith · 2026
- Shared notes
- Black tea, Lime

Malibù - Party in the Bay 5th Anniversary
Simone Andreoli · 2023
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

100% Pure Chipie Green
Chipie · 1998
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Moon Drunk (Perfume Oil)
The Strange South · 2018
- Shared notes
- Lime, Rum

Bay Rum (All Purpose Fragrance)
O'Douds
- Shared notes
- Laurel, Lime