Perfumes similar to Bay Rum and Lime
The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with First Canadian Shave Bay Rum and Lime. The closest match is Black Ship Grooming Co. Black Beard. The notes shared most often on this list: Lime, Patchouli, and Bay rum.
Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Black Beard
Black Ship Grooming Co.
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Lime

Bay Rhum
Long Rifle
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Lime

Bay Rum With a Twist
Saint Charles Shave
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Lime

Enciende for Him
Mercadona
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Sky Line
Zermat
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Crunchy Girl
Humphrey's Handmade
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Bay Rum, Limes & Peppercorn
Ogallala Bay Rum
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Lime

Barbershop
H|S|S|C - Highland Springs Soap Co.
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Patchouli

Swashbuckler
Arcana Wildcraft · 2008
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Lime

Sex
Enfleurage
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Dune
Linnic
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Firdous
Surrati
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Black Pepper & Lime
The Beer Soap Co.
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Rum Bay Rum
D.S. & Durga · 2025
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Lime

Wonderful India...
Jimmy Boyd
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Thai Lime
COA
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Coconut Bay w/ Lime! (Aftershave & Cologne)
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Lime

Green Carnation
Alkemia
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Patchouli

Bay Rum
Jeeves of Hudson Street
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Patchouli

Dolce Vita
Twinkle Apothecary
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Neil Gaiman's Anansi Boys - Mr. Nancy
Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab · 2007
- Shared notes
- Bay rum, Lime

Lilac + Lime
Henny Faire Co.
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Happiness
Perfume by Nature
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli

Frankenstein
The Mindful Mushroom
- Shared notes
- Lime, Patchouli