Perfumes similar to All the Colors of the Dark
The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Pulp Fragrance All the Colors of the Dark. The closest match is Eldritch Whispers Mother of Puppets (Eau de Parfum). The notes shared most often on this list: Clove, Aniseed, and Neroli.
Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Mother of Puppets (Eau de Parfum)
Eldritch Whispers
- Shared notes
- Aniseed, Black liquorice, Clove

Lü Bu
6.9Sora Dora · 2025
- Shared notes
- Amyris, Clove, Metallic notes, Tonka bean absolute

Sound of a Ricochet
7.8Floraïku · 2017
- Shared notes
- Amyris, Aniseed, Tonka bean absolute

Bay Rum
Ten Digit Creations
- Shared notes
- Clove, Fruits

Divine Essence 1 / Sparkling Citrus
JoAnne Bassett · 2005
- Shared notes
- Clove, Neroli

Marshmallows, Gumdrops, and Peppermint Canes
Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab · 2021
- Shared notes
- Aniseed, Clove

Maggiore
Berani · 2020
- Shared notes
- Amyris, Aniseed, Clove

Amber Vanilla (Solid Balm)
Essensorie
- Shared notes
- Amyris, Aniseed, Clove

Marrakech
6.5Aēsop · 2005
- Shared notes
- Clove, Neroli

209 Styrax
LabSolue
- Shared notes
- Amyris, Tonka bean absolute

Wedge
NSHQ
- Shared notes
- Clove, Fruits

Šljiva
Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab · 2026
- Shared notes
- Aniseed, Clove

Heat
The Sage Goddess
- Shared notes
- Aniseed, Clove

Miss Bella Wyatt
Violette Market · 2008
- Shared notes
- Aniseed, Black liquorice

Wormwood (Eau de Parfum)
Sucreabeille · 2018
- Shared notes
- Aniseed, Clove

Tobacco - Florets in Bloom
Age of Earth Collective
- Shared notes
- Amyris, Clove

Hazel
J.Hannah Co.
- Shared notes
- Fruits, Neroli

Les Nombres d'Or - Musc
7.6Maison Mona di Orio · 2010
- Shared notes
- Neroli, Tonka bean absolute

Ambr'Erò
7.2Cerchi Nell'Acqua
- Shared notes
- Clove, Neroli

Tubéreuse du Mexique
7.9Buly · 2014
- Shared notes
- Clove, Fruits

Darling
7.0Vanessa Megan
- Shared notes
- Clove, Neroli

India Ink (Eau de Parfum)
Heretic · 2016
- Shared notes
- Amyris, Clove

Metamorphosis
Lush · 2018
- Shared notes
- Clove, Neroli

Histoire d'Orangers
7.7L'Artisan Parfumeur · 2017
- Shared notes
- Neroli, Tonka bean absolute