Skip to content
Parfumedia

Perfumes similar to Sugar Cookie

The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Scentsy Sugar Cookie. The closest match is Sand + Fog White Vanilla (Eau de Parfum Oil), at 45% similarity. The notes shared most often on this list: Sugar, Vanilla, and Butter.

Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Back to Sugar Cookie
  1. Sand + Fog White Vanilla (Eau de Parfum Oil) perfume bottle45% match

    White Vanilla (Eau de Parfum Oil)

    9.0

    Sand + Fog

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  2. Coco & Rose Dreamy Buttercream perfume bottle45% match

    Dreamy Buttercream

    Coco & Rose · 2024

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  3. Siren Song Elixirs Candy Corn perfume bottle45% match

    Candy Corn

    Siren Song Elixirs · 2019

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  4. Dirty Soul Soap Co. Vanilla Wafers (Parfum Mist) perfume bottle45% match

    Vanilla Wafers (Parfum Mist)

    Dirty Soul Soap Co.

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  5. Dirty Soul Soap Co. Butter Cookies (Parfum Mist) perfume bottle45% match

    Butter Cookies (Parfum Mist)

    Dirty Soul Soap Co.

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  6. Demeter Fragrance Library Marshmallow (Cologne) perfume bottle40% match

    Marshmallow (Cologne)

    5.5

    Demeter Fragrance Library

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  7. Jessica Simpson Dessert Treats - Cupcake perfume bottle40% match

    Dessert Treats - Cupcake

    Jessica Simpson · 2004

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  8. Victoria's Secret Candy, Baby perfume bottle40% match

    Candy, Baby

    Victoria's Secret · 2012

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  9. Hollister Sugar and Vanilla perfume bottle40% match

    Sugar and Vanilla

    Hollister

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  10. Jessica Simpson Dessert Treats - Vanilla Ice Cream perfume bottle40% match

    Dessert Treats - Vanilla Ice Cream

    Jessica Simpson · 2006

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  11. Refan Sweet Vanilla perfume bottle40% match

    Sweet Vanilla

    Refan

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  12. Humphrey's Handmade Vanilla perfume bottle40% match

    Vanilla

    Humphrey's Handmade

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  13. scentXscent Vanilla Darling perfume bottle40% match

    Vanilla Darling

    scentXscent · 2026

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  14. Poesie Perfume Sucre Vanille perfume bottle40% match

    Sucre Vanille

    Poesie Perfume · 2018

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  15. EMES #201 Fresh Cream perfume bottle40% match

    #201 Fresh Cream

    EMES

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  16. Ulta Sugared Vanilla perfume bottle40% match

    Sugared Vanilla

    Ulta · 2016

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  17. Deep Steep Brown Sugar - Vanilla perfume bottle40% match

    Brown Sugar - Vanilla

    Deep Steep

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  18. INGRID Velvet Vanilla perfume bottle40% match

    Velvet Vanilla

    INGRID · 2025

    Shared notes
    Sugar, Vanilla
  19. Possets Heart Attack perfume bottle

    Heart Attack

    Possets · 2009

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  20. Dirty Soul Soap Co. Pink Sprinkle Donut perfume bottle

    Pink Sprinkle Donut

    Dirty Soul Soap Co.

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  21. Coco & Rose Birthday Cake (Eau de Parfum) perfume bottle

    Birthday Cake (Eau de Parfum)

    Coco & Rose

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  22. VampressHeart Ginger Dead perfume bottle

    Ginger Dead

    VampressHeart

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  23. Coco & Rose Ice Cream Sundae perfume bottle

    Ice Cream Sundae

    Coco & Rose · 2023

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla
  24. Bottega Verde Caffè perfume bottle

    Caffè

    Bottega Verde · 2026

    Shared notes
    Butter, Sugar, Vanilla