Perfumes similar to Apple Pie & Custard
The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Sorceress Apple Pie & Custard. The closest match is Demeter Fragrance Library Crème Anglaise (Cologne). The notes shared most often on this list: Vanilla cream and Apple pie.
Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Crème Anglaise (Cologne)
6.1Demeter Fragrance Library · 2017
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Sugared Vanilla / Vanille Sucrée (Eau de Toilette)
Ulta
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Apple Pie
Star Nature
- Shared notes
- Apple pie

Vanilla Custard - Fish Fingers not included - Doctor Who
Bubble and Geek
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Vanilla Cream
Lurker & Strange
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Pink - Pumpkin Vanilla
Victoria's Secret · 2026
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Orange Creamsicle
Sugar Me Sweet
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Cardamom Vanilla
Naiad Soap Arts
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Sugared Vanilla Bean
bodycology · 2012
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Coconut Cream
Spectrum Cosmetic
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Orange Creme Swirl
Violette Market · 2012
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Pi in the Sky
Alkemia · 2019
- Shared notes
- Apple pie

Custard Cream
Sorceress
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Yule 2014 - Christmas Pudding
Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab · 2014
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Unicorn Cake
Theme
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

White Gardenia & Vanilla Cream
Black Phoenix Alchemy Lab · 2019
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Iced Coffee
Sugar Me Sweet
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Black Raspberry & Vanilla
Dirty Soul Soap Co.
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Assembled Vengeance - Star Spangled
Elden Fragrances · 2018
- Shared notes
- Apple pie

Vanilla Pear
Cocoa Pink
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Desire
Chic
- Shared notes
- Apple pie

Marshmallow
Lip Smacker · 2025
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Crystal Shores
Hollister
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream

Demesne (Perfume Oil)
Sucreabeille
- Shared notes
- Vanilla cream