Perfumes similar to Bay Rum
The 24 perfumes whose notes and accords overlap most with Stephanie K Bay Rum. The closest match is Weltenduft Antina. The notes shared most often on this list: Clove, Orange, and Laurel.
Ranking: similarity from shared notes (60%) and shared accords (40%).

Antina
Weltenduft
- Shared notes
- Clove, Laurel

Bay Rum
Charles H. Baldwin & Sons
- Shared notes
- Clove, Laurel

Bay Rum
Subtle Art Soap Co.
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove, Laurel

Madagascar Spice (Perfume)
Pacifica
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Pomerander
Lizzy Lane Farm
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Bay Rum
Abraham's
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Orange Lemon & Clove
Mind Over Lather
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Casanova's
Burly Stone
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove, Amyris

Quoth the Raven
Sea Witch Botanicals
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Orange Spice
A Wing & A Prayer Perfumes
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Magens Bay
Nomad Theory · 2025
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove, Amyris

The Pope's Cologne Pius IX
Excelsis
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Glühwein (Parfümöl)
Wolkenseifen
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Fireplace
Firebird · 2017
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Clove Pomander
Voluspa
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

The New Now - Gratitude
Salad Code · 2021
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Distillate (Perfume Oil)
Sucreabeille
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Burning Leaves (Eau de Parfum)
Posh Goth
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Solar Eclipse
Amorphous · 2017
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Bay Laurel (Aftershave)
Stirling Soap
- Shared notes
- Orange, Laurel

Astral Temple (2011)
Solstice Scents · 2011
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Amsterdam
Nina's Nature · 2012
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove

Tobacco - Florets in Bloom
Age of Earth Collective
- Shared notes
- Clove, Amyris

Instinct
Les Floralies · 1993
- Shared notes
- Orange, Clove